This week’s Torah portion, Vayikra, discusses many of the korbanos (sacrificial offerings in the Temple). Nowadays we no longer have these offerings, and our Sages taught that prayer is said in place of Korbanos, as the verse says (Hoshea 14:3) “Uneshalma parim sefaseinu. We will offer cows with our lips”. There is a rabbinical mitzva to pray with a minyan, group of at least ten whenever it is possible.
How would you answer the following true story that deals with the mitzva to prae2dy with a minyan?
There was a busy shul in Israel located near a hospital. There was a chronic problem in the shul that cell phones kept ringing during the prayers. The shul officers tried cajoling, and campaigns, but nothing helped. Finally, in desperation, after many initiatives, the shul’s officers decided that they would take the drastic measure of purchasing a “cell phone jammer”. This is a device that blocks all cell reception within a building. The phone ringing in shul stopped immediately. The shul officers were ecstatic.
Because the shul was located near a hospital, many doctors who were on call would pray at the shul. When the doctors heard that their cell reception was blocked, they immediately complained. They had to be in constant communication with the hospital and their patients. It was often a matter of saving lives. If they couldn’t get any cell reception, that would force them not to daven in that shul and they would not be able to daven with a minyan as result. There was no other minyan nearby. They insisted that the cell jammer be removed and they would instead make sure to keep their phones on vibrate. Otherwise the shul’s new policy was excluding them from the shul. On the other hand, the shul officers felt that the benefits of having no phones ringing in the shul outweighed the cost of potentially excluding the doctors who needed reception at all times.
Who do you think? Can the shul keep the cell jammer if it will force the doctors to daven alone?
Answer for last week’s moral dilemma
According the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein, one should be willing to spend a very large amount of money in order to the gain a sincere forgiveness from one he aggrieved. See Chashuki Chemed Yuma Page 589
Click HERE if you would like to receive this question as an email each week.