An envelope containing 25 checks mailed from the Nottingham Post Office in Baltimore County never reached its destination. Three of the checks later surfaced with altered amounts totaling more than $35,000, according to WMAR-2 News.

The checks, worth approximately $5,655 altogether, were intended to pay for tickets to a community crab feast. On September 5, the organization’s secretary deposited the envelope into a mailbox inside the post office on Mercantile Boulevard. It was addressed to Solomons, Maryland, but never arrived.

Madge Jones, who chaired the crab feast committee, had written two of the checks. One, originally for $2,325, was altered to $8,000 and made payable to someone she did not recognize. Another, originally for $150, was changed to $4,612.97 and used to pay a BGE bill. A third check from the envelope, originally worth $75, was altered to $23,041.52.

The missing checks also created financial difficulties for the organization, which discovered at its September 27 crab feast that it did not have enough money in its account to pay vendors. Jones used personal checks to help cover expenses, but one of those checks bounced.

Most of the money involved in the identified transactions has been recovered or reimbursed, but $8,000 remains tied up while banks investigate. The woman who mailed the envelope has filed complaints with postal authorities and police. No one has established where the envelope disappeared or who may have taken the checks.

The case comes as a federal audit has raised concerns about mail security at the Nottingham Post Office and three other Baltimore-area postal facilities. The USPS Office of Inspector General found three missing or lost arrow keys at Nottingham, along with four additional keys that were not properly recorded in the facility’s inventory. Arrow keys allow postal employees to access collection boxes and other mail receptacles.

Auditors warned that inadequate oversight of these keys increases the risk of mail theft. However, the audit did not establish any connection between the missing keys and the checks in this case.

This article was independently written by the BJL Newsroom based on reporting from WMAR-2 News.