Baltimore, MD - July 21, 2023  - Yesterday,  at approximate noon, Rabbi Jonathan Aryeh Seidemann was on his way home from his shul’s office for a quick lunch only to arrive at his home to a scene reminiscent of a movie set from a crime thriller with a couple dozen police vehicles and dozens of armed agents with rifles surrounding his home.


It turns out that Rabbi & Mrs Seidemann’s daughter and son-in-law from Ohio were in town for a visit at a time when Ohio police happened to be searching throughout the US for a certain criminal.

Apparently, before this cell phone # was assigned by the phone company to Rabbi Seidemann’s son-in-law already a couple of years ago, it must have originally been the criminal’s phone number and since their children were visiting from their home in Ohio, the criminal's hometown, the number pinged at the Seidemann’s house.

The Ohio fugitive task force thought they had their man and contacted the local authorities, US Marshals, State Troopers, and local police. When the “cavalry” arrived and saw an Ohio license tag on a van in the Seidemann’s driveway, they were convinced they had their OHIO fugitive.

Rabbi Seidemann confirmed to BJL that  upon realizing the mix up, the incident ended on a very friendly note as the law enforcement personnel were very apologetic and Rabbi Seidemann expressed our community’s gratitude for their general service in protecting our community.

Anecdotally, one of Rabbi and Mrs. Seidemann‘s daughters observed and conveyed to BJL that there is a tremendous lesson one can deduce from the experience.  She points out that here law enforcement thought they had ironclad information; an Ohio phone number showing up at a Baltimore home, a van with Ohio tags in the driveway, and with all that, the information was completely mistaken.

How often, she pointed out, do we think we know everything about a situation and draw conclusions about another, which can be completely mistaken. It’s a wonderful reminder of how to think of and judge others, especially during these three weeks.