Jerusalem, Israel - July 6, 2022 - E1 is short for East 1 - the land area immediately east of Jerusalem, Israel, from French Hill toward Ma'ale Adumim.  E1 covers an area of 12 square kilometers (4.6 sq mi).

The story of E1 has been unfolding since before 2009 when demolition orders were issued for Khan al-Ahmar, the Bedouin encampment near the entrance road to Ma'ale Adumim. The number of dwellings has grown over the years to include an UN-sponsored school building.

In March 2022,  the Israeli High Court of Justice issued a conditional order in the Khan al-Ahmar case. The order, gave the government 120 days to explain its failure to fulfill the three-year-old commitment to enforcing the law “in the near future." 

The demolition order has been repeatedly ignored by the Israeli government. Repeated appeals to the Supreme Court have upheld the illegal status of Khan al-Ahmar. Israel has tried to provide alternate locations for the Jahalin Bedouin clan to settle. They have refused all offers to resettle.

On Monday, prior to the July 13 visit of US President Joe Biden to the region, BJL participated in a tour led by MediaCentral for journalists to see the contested E1. The area is considered likely to arise in discussions with the Biden administration. Israel sees the E1 corridor as crucial to connect Jerusalem with the 30,000 residents of Ma'ale Adumim. 

From a lookout in Ma’aleh Adumim, Rafael Engel, Deputy Head of the Binyamin Regional Council pointed out details along the E1 corridor.  Across Wadi Abu Hindi - Kedar, the strip of land and road, there are buildings, some with no windows, built without permits. Also, the lack of proper sewage disposal is visible for these buildings in Area B - under the Palestinian Authority on land under Israel's security.

Under the terms of the Oslo agreement, in Judea and Samaria (West Bank) Area A is under Palestinian Authority administrative and police control. While in Area B, the PA has administrative control but shares security control with Israeli authorities. Area C is under Israeli control and security.

The NGO Regavim has led the cause to prevent the illegal seizure of state land and "to protect the rule of law and clean government in matters pertaining to land-use policy in the State of Israel." International Division Director Naomi Kahn informed us, "people are not allowed to move in to those buildings. They are not natural growth, but transferred for political reasons." She further stated, "Relocation is to increase population density in critical areas. And Israel is quiet." Meanwhile, the EU promotes illegal transfer by building schools, already 100 illegal schools in Area C. Further, she added, "They should invest in B, but Palestinian Authority's focus is on C - to undermine Israel."

Regavim has tracked with maps the illegal growth of multiple Bedouin sites. All the nomad tribes need to set up camp is water. Look for a water tank and soon you will find people living nearby Kahn said, showing printed illustrations and photographs to support her statements.

Boaz Ido, Head of the Jerusalem Environs Forum stood above the Khan al-Ahmar site which has been torn down and restarted multiple times, and expressed his regrets that there has been no conclusion to the ongoing saga. As a long-time resident in the area and neighbor, he has good relations with Bedouin neighbors and wants to live and work together.  He supports the claims of Regavim that the people involved are political pawns whose lives are not being made better by the PA leadership.

To conclude the tour, a drive was made up a dirt road to a vantage point near al-Eizariya, not far from Ma'aleh Adumim, where the new mayor, Khalil Abu Reesh, stood for an interview. The "45,000 people of al-Eizariya demand our land" he stated. "E1 project takes thousands of dunams, the families need open spaces for their animals." Further, he insisted, the Israelis took the water springs. "They destroy, we rebuild." He called, E 1 a second nakba for the Bedouin." 

Al-Eizariya or al-Azariya, also known as Bethany, is minutes from Jerusalem. Abu Reesh expressed concern the Biden visit will be an opportunity for Israelis to take advantage. He feels they are the same as Ukraine but not seen that way. 

The feeling that his people are being used as in a game of chess is hard to refute.

In the photo essay, BJL presents photographs to highlight points made in this piece, which is an oversimplification of a complicated and long-drawn-out issue. Lives are at stake. The solution remains to be seen.