In a community where criticism of [former] President Obama was rampant, where respectful dialogue was exchanged with ridicule, and where a difference of opinion metamorphosed into open accusations, we were reprimanded.

Right here, in these hallowed pages of Hamodia Features we were taught that there is no place for scornful rhetoric. We were opined to, that the [former] president is not anti-Israel and most certainly not anti-Semitic. Much effort was put into attempting to substantiating these theories. We were put on notice that to talk about the [former] president through the medium of disparaging adjectives is completely wrong.

Our admonisher did point out, though, that his chastisement of our behavior did not necessarily reflect a pro-President Obama attitude, but rather a respect of the office of the democratically elected president of the United States of America.

In a country where criticism of President Trump is rampant, where respectful dialogue is exchanged with ridicule, and where a difference of opinion leads directly to open accusations, who will teach us to abandon scornful rhetoric? Who will convey to us the importance of avoiding disparaging adjectives? Who will defend the honor of the office of the democratically elected president of the United States of America? Where is the voice of our admonisher? Where is Rabbi Avi Shafran?

Mordechai Lipton, Jerusalem

Rabbi Shafran responds: I’m here, baruch Hashem, and fine. Thanks for asking.

Columnists in many media write to please their readers, to offer them confirmation of their preconceived beliefs and opinions; other columnists aim instead to stimulate thought and even, at times, to challenge their readers’ prior perceptions. I am among the second species.

When I argued over the Obama years that the then-president was being portrayed one-dimensionally and in a misleadingly negative fashion regarding his attitude toward Israel, it was not, at least not mainly, to show deference to an elected leader, but rather to supply pertinent information I saw missing from the public conversation.

If I were to perceive unfairly negative attitudes toward the current president in our community, I would just as surely address that, too. But I don’t; if anything, much of our community, rightly or otherwise, deeply admires the president. And so I choose to turn my attention to more meaningful commentary.

Thanks for your letter and best wishes.